With the election just two days away, I herein reveal my fearless forecast. I analyze the forces favoring each political party in the approximate order of importance. Also, I call the key individual senate races.
Factors Favoring Democrats
-
Historical Advantage: The party in power has gained seats only twice since 1900 in midterm elections. The Dems (FDR) won in 1934 in the midst of the Great Depression, and in 2002 the GOP (Bush) won in the aftermath of 9-11. That’s 2 out of 31 times or only 6%. That is a strong tailwind for Dems.
-
Trump’s Low Approval Rating: Trump’s approval rating is 38% and his disapproval stands at 60%. These are not good numbers.
-
Energy Prices, Inflation and Affordability: The price of gas and diesel undoubtedly is a headwind for the GOP as is affordability overall.
-
Generic Ballot: The average of various polls shows Dems up 7 to 8 points.
-
Iran War: I listed this only to show I had not forgotten about it. By all accounts this is not a major issue for voters.
Factors Favoring Republicans
-
Money: The GOP has significantly outspent the Dems. This helped get their message across, and importantly funded their get out the vote ground game.
-
Polling Errors: Most polls are unreliable; many intentionally overstate the Dem advantage to suppress the GOP vote. In Dem primaries in WI and MI, the polls were off a whopping 20 to 30 points. Even good pollsters undercount the GOP by several points. Any election within the margin of error will go GOP.
-
Candidate Quality: This is a huge advantage for the GOP in states such as Maine, Wisconsin, Michigan, Florida and others.
-
Trump Barnstorming: Don’t underestimate the effect Trump rallies have had on motivating GOP voters.
-
Early Voting: In states with early voting, turnout among GOP voters is running ahead of benchmarks based on prior elections. Seniors, who break heavily Republican, are voting in large numbers – possibly a harbinger of a silver wave. Conversely, Democrat-leaning young voters are under represented.
-
Socialism and DSA Craziness: Americans (especially older ones) abhor socialism; that will also affect races other than where DSA candidates are running. Then there is the crazy factor; some Dems espouse ideas that can only be described as crazy, such as abolishing police and the military, open borders and Medicare for all. Then the Dems have Hasan Piker, who says America deserved 9-11. Dems are on the wrong side of every 80/20 and 90/10 issue.
Wild Card
There are three issues that will determine the outcome; they are (1) turnout, (2) turnout and (3) turnout. In the 2024 election, 158 million people voted, whereas in the 2022 midterm election only 112 million voted. This means that 46 million fewer people or 30% less voted in the last midterm. More than any other factor, turnout will determine the outcome – with a high turnout favoring Republicans.
Key Senate Races
Senators in the classes of 2028 and 2030 are not up for election; this includes 33 GOP and 34 Dems. In the class of 2026, there are 15 seats safe for the GOP and 9 for the Dems. This equates to 48 GOP seats and 43 Dem seats. Thus, 91 seats either are not up for election or are considered noncompetitive. That leaves 9 states still in play: Texas, Alaska, Iowa, North Carolina, New Hampshire, Georgia, Minnesota, Michigan and Maine. Following is my fearless forecast for those crucial 9 states.
-
Alaska: This is the hardest to handicap due to ranked voting and two candidates with the same name. Alaska is a toss-up, but I pick the GOP in a nail biter.
-
Georgia: This will go blue even though early voting favored the GOP.
-
Iowa: Chalk this up for the GOP, although it will be closer than it should be.
-
Maine: Collins will win, likely by several points over a flawed opponent.
-
Michigan: El-Sayed is losing among African Americans, union members and Jewish voters. This race should not be close; the GOP wins.
-
Minnesota: In an upset special, the GOP will flip this deep blue state.
-
New Hampshire: The GOP will come tantalizingly close, but will fall short.
-
North Carolina: This looks to be solidly a win for the Dems.
-
Texas: The GOP candidate is flawed, but the Dem candidate is crazy. Chalk this one up for the GOP. The Dems might have won with a strong candidate.
The 9 states still in play will break 6 GOP and 3 Dem. This means that the Senate will be 54 GOP and 46 Dem. If I am wrong about Alaska and Minnesota, the Senate will be 52 to 48 in favor of Republicans. Democrats would still need to win 3 out of 4 seats from Iowa, Maine, Michigan and Texas to take control of the Senate.
Republicans will control the Senate 54 to 46, but do no worse than 52 to 48.
Based on the above analysis, my fearless forecast is that Republicans hold the Senate by 54 to 46, but should be no worse off than 52 to 48.
House of Representatives
I don’t have enough granular data to forecast the House. There are fewer than 20 seats up for grabs. If forced to opine, I would guess Democrats narrowly win control.
Election 2026
I have made my fearless forecast, but humbly acknowledge there is a wide range of possible outcomes, with turnout being the wild card. There could be a blue wave if voters sour on Trump and blame the GOP (whether rightly or wrongly) for high prices. There could be a red wave if voters punish Dems for socialism, craziness and being on the wrong side of every 80/20 issue. As always, voters will have the final say.
[{“id”:”custom_html”,”tag”:”<a href="Read More“>Original on Substack”}]