Suicidal Empathy is the title of a recently published nonfiction book by Gad Saad. This is only the third book review I have published in 20 years of blogging and is a must read. It cogently explains why progressives advocate policies, cultural norms and moral judgments that prioritize emotional validation over truth, reason and even over societal preservation – they literally choose suicide by rejecting objective reality.
Saad contends Western Civilization has corrupted one of humanity’s signal virtues (empathy) which is essential for social cohesion. Saad argues contemporary progressive politics risks suicide by promoting narratives that override empirical evidence.
Too little empathy results in psychopathy; too much risks civilizational suicide.
Empathy Gone Dangerously Wrong
Cultural and psychological beliefs amplify destructive empathy in many ways. Elites engage in virtue signaling that imposes costs and risks on others. They symbolically support causes without making any meaningful sacrifices. They suppress or deny inconvenient truths to protect marginalized groups from discomfort. These behaviors result in victimhood being valorized, criminals prioritized over victims and truth being sacrificed on the altar of emotional narratives.
Civilizations die by suicide rather than murder (Toynbee). Liberalism is the ideology of Western suicide (Burnham).
Suicidal empathy is a unique form of self-destruction – one not driven by violence or nihilism – but by misguided empathy when emotions eclipse reason and common sense. It results when compassion is applied in ways that may feel morally virtuous, but ultimately produce harm to people, institutions and society.
Not surprisingly, women consistently score higher in empathy, which makes them more susceptible to emotion and suicidal empathy. This explains why women, often by substantial margins, vote progressive while men vote conservative.
Unchecked empathy threatens the foundation of Western Civilization. (Saad)
Examples of Suicidal Empathy
Crime and Justice
Empathy leads to cashless bail and the release of violent criminals with a long history of crime. Over-lenient sentencing, early parole, failure to prosecute shoplifting, and drug crimes all result in more crime and more victims. Empathy prioritizes criminals over public safety.
Immigration and Borders
Unvetted mass entry, by abolishing borders, releases terrorists, murderers, gangbangers, child rapists and the criminally insane into the US. Sanctuary cities release hardened criminals and refuse to cooperate with ICE. Such immigration raises the cost of housing, healthcare, and welfare – often crowding out citizens. Empathy assumes all cultures, including those advocating our destruction, can be assimilated.
Education and Research
Research that contradicts progressive narratives is suppressed and the authors canceled. Grades are inflated, college admissions are dumbed down and standards are lowered out of empathy to protected groups.
Climate Change
Climate alarmism, (not singled out by Saad) elevated to the status of a religion by its acolytes, is the most destructive example extant where science was ignored in favor of a narrative embraced by the progressive elite. Along with open borders, and unassimilated immigrants, it has nearly destroyed the economy of Western Europe.
Culture and Other
Empathy prioritizes feelings above facts. Victimhood is valorized and unfounded assertions of oppression and fabricated grievances are rewarded. Welfare provides unconditional benefits to druggies and homeless without requiring accountability. Instead of helping, such policies trap the recipients in dependency. Progressives, out of misguided empathy, permit homeless encampments to degrade the lives of citizens, while turning cities into open drug markets and open sewers.
Suicidal Empathy
Suicidal empathy is a stark warning to Americans and Western Civilization. Empathy, when misdirected or excessive, is a destructive force that can lead to societal suicide. Saad calls for a return to balanced empathy – compassion moderated by rationality, truth and empirical evidence. We must not allow America to become sheep that invite the progressive wolves for dinner.
Note to subscribers: After 20 years of blogging I am changing the frequency of my postings. I will continue (usually) to post on Sunday mornings – just not every week.
[{“id”:”custom_html”,”tag”:”<a href="Read More“>Original on Substack”}]



